|
FROM THE NEWS ARCHIVES OF DVDFANATIC.COM
HD DVD vs BLU-RAY COMPARISON: "Ocean's Thirteen"
POSTED
ON
11/19/07 AT 7:30 A.M.
By Eric Klein
Ocean's Twelve sucked! Thankfully, Ocean's
Thirteen is an entertaining romp that, while not as successful as the
first film, is a great diversion worth a viewing. George Clooney and company
return to the revelry of Ocean's Eleven with the addition of a
scene chewing Al Pacino and a perfectly cast Ellen Barkin. Although Julia
Roberts sat the film out, her presence is not all that missed. This is a boy's
club after all.
THE FILM: Danny Ocean (Clooney) has an idea for
one more score. The biggest that they could do, Ocean reassembles his crew of
Basher (Don Cheadle), Rusty (Brad Pitt) and others (including Matt Damon, Scott
Caan, Casey Affleck, Elliot Gould and Carl Reiner). Ocean's bunch's new target
is Willie Bank, a Las Vegas Mogul setting up shop with a brand new casino.
Bank double-crossed Reuben (Gould) and now the crew is out to get revenge.
Enlisting the help of Terry Benedict (Andy Garcia), Ocean goes through persona
after persona to plot out when gigantic heist. Drawing on the charm of the first
film and involving a confusing yet fun to follow heist, Ocean's Thirteen is a
big step up from its predecessors.
The crew is now letting the audience in on the joke, while the script by
Brian Koppelman and David Levein brings shape to what could have been a formless
gabfest. If you are in the mode for a breezy and brisk film this is the ticket.
HD SOUND + VISION: The HD DVD and Blu-ray
releases of Ocean's Thirteen share very similar specs. Both
feature a decent 2.40:1 visual presentation. The source material is digital
video so the finished product does feature grain inherent within the frame. The
quality of the transfer is decent, doing a nice job preserving the visual
quality that is present. Certainly sharper than the DVD, both the HD DVD and
Blu-ray are not essential visual releases.
The audio for the HD DVD features a Dolby Digital Plus selection of tracks,
while the Blu-ray disc simply features Dolby Digital audio. Both are decent
presentations that capture the clanging of the casino floor. Without anything
particularly impressive, the HD DVD gets the edge for its slightly improved
specs. The subtitles included are English, French, Spanish, Portuguese, Chinese
and Korean while there are also French and Spanish audio tracks on each release.
PACKAGING/ LAYOUT: Both releases feature
similar presentation. The HD DVD arrives in a red Elite case, the Blu-ray in a
blue one. While the Blu-ray features a modified version of the DVD's disc art,
the HD DVD is a combo release, complete with the DVD on one side and the HD DVD
on the other. The menu designs are similar, with the only notable difference
being the inclusion of a "Bookmark" feature on the HD DVD. A solid overall
presentation, both releases feature a more intuitive menu than previous
Warner Home Entertainment releases. When one goes to choose "Scene
Selections" while playing back a bonus feature, the disc recognizes such and
offers an option for the viewer. "There are no scene selections for this special
feature. Would you like the scene selections for the main feature?" A very nice
addition indeed.
SPECIAL FEATURES: A paltry selection of special
features is included in this release. Most are carried over featurettes from the
DVD that offer little more than a cursory look at the making of the film. The
one nice high definition exclusive (included on both the HD DVD and Blu-ray
Disc) is a commentary track with Director Steven Soderbergh and the two writers
of the film. An insightful, fun and quick paced track, this is certainly worth
picking up a high definition copy of the film.
- Commentary by Director Steven Soderbergh, Screen Writers Brian
Koppelman and David Levein HD EXCLUSIVE - A great track, these three
were recorded both separately and together. They introduce the commentary as a
trio, but comments pipe in and out from different recording sessions. All and
all, certainly worth a listen.
- Masters of the Heist HD EXCLUSIVE (44:02) - A look at the real
life heists that people like the Ocean crew pulled off, this is a great,
entertaining featurette. It is not the most current of features, but presented
in high definition it is certainly an entertaining time.
- Additional Scenes (4:36) - A series of brief moments, most of them just extended scenes
that are all presented in high definition.
- Vegas: An Opulent Illusion (22:47) - The Vegas design sense is discussed as creative individuals and
Las Vegas experts come together to discuss the aesthetic and tone of the city.
A nice featurette considering the topic of the film and the prevalence of
launching a hotel in the plot.
- Jerry Weintraub Walk and Talk (2:25) - The producer of the film
walks us through the set of the Bank's Casino in this shameless promotional
featurette.
FINAL THOUGHTS: Not the best in the series,
Ocean's Thirteen is certainly a quality distraction worth a
viewing. The visuals may not be particularly strong in HD, the overall
presentation makes the release worth a look. While the HD DVD and Blu-ray Disc
are barely different, the HD DVD gets the edge with an improved audio track.
Now, if it was just a couple of dollars cheaper.
BLU-RAY DISC FILM GRADE: B
HD SOUND GRADE: B- HD VISION: B- PACKAGING/ LAYOUT GRADE: B-
SPECIAL FEATURES GRADE: B+ OVERALL BLU-RAY DISC GRADE:
B-
HD DVD FILM GRADE: B HD
SOUND GRADE: B HD VISION: B- PACKAGING/ LAYOUT GRADE: B SPECIAL
FEATURES GRADE: B+ OVERALL HD DVD DISC GRADE: B
COMPARISON FILM GRADE: N/A
HD SOUND GRADE: HD DVD HD VISION GRADE: N/A PACKAGING/ LAYOUT GRADE:
HD DVD SPECIAL FEATURES GRADE: N/A THE CHOICE: HD DVD |